Breaking In Leather Is Better!
Why Breaking In Leather Is Better Than Receiving One “Already Broke In”
When investing in a premium leather holster, many gun owners face the choice: buy it brand-new and break it in yourself, or purchase one that’s already been “broke in.” While the second option might seem easier, it almost always sacrifices safety, durability, and comfort. According to Urban Carry Holsters and other top leather holster manufacturers, the break-in process is more than tradition—it’s essential for performance.
1. Safer Retention and Draw Control
Custom Fit for Your Firearm
A new leather holster is intentionally stiff, providing maximum firearm retention and preventing accidental dislodging. Breaking it in yourself allows it to mold exactly to your weapon’s dimensions, ensuring both security and a smooth draw.
Protection for Your Gear
A personal break-in reduces friction wear on your gun. By gradually easing the leather, you protect the finish and maintain the integrity of both your firearm and the holster.
2. Longer-Lasting Leather Performance
Avoid Overstretching
Pre-broken leather often loses structural integrity quickly. A careful, user-controlled break-in process—such as the plastic or cloth bag method ensures the leather softens naturally without overstretching.
Built for the Long Haul
High-quality saddle leather, like that used in Urban Carry’s designs, can last for decades when broken in correctly. Gradual wear strengthens fibers while maintaining shape.
3. Comfort That Adapts to You
Molds to Your Body
When you wear a holster daily, your body shape, carry position, and movement patterns are unique. Breaking it in yourself ensures it molds to your contours—not to someone else’s.
The Urban Carry Advantage
Urban Carry’s G3 holster for example, uses pre-conditioned leather to speed up the process, but still requires a few days of use to perfect the fit.
4. Fit and Retention You Can Trust
Balance Between Grip and Draw
The perfect holster retention keeps your firearm secure while allowing a smooth, confident draw. Self-breaking in leather lets you achieve this balance naturally.
Works with Modern Retention Systems
Even with innovations like Urban Carry’s LockLeather™ click retention, a short break-in period improves draw smoothness without compromising safety.
Proven Leather Holster Break-In Methods
| Method | Process | Benefit |
|---|---|---|
| Cloth Bag | Wrap unloaded firearm in a cloth bag the holster was shipped in, insert and leave overnight | Gentle stretch without damage |
| Plastic Bag | Wrap unloaded firearm in a plastic bag, insert and leave overnight | Gentle stretch without damage |
| Daily Wear | Carry holster during normal activities | Natural shaping for firearm & body |
| Leather Conditioner | Apply coat of conditioner, insert in holster and leave overnight (can be combined with above methods) | Faster break-in |
Avoid: heat, water soaking, heavy oils—these will damage leather.
Conclusion
Breaking in a leather holster yourself:
-
Improves safety with firearm-specific retention
-
Extends lifespan by avoiding premature wear
-
Maximizes comfort through personal molding
-
Optimizes fit for secure carry and smooth draw
Your leather holster is more than a carry accessory—it’s an investment. Give it the time it deserves, and it will serve you for years with unmatched comfort, safety, and style.
REMEMBER: Always start with an unloaded firearm and ensure safety first!
Richard Calvette
Firearms Expert, Urban Carry Holsters
I've been with Urban Carry Holsters since 2020, proudly serving as the Firearms Expert. Before that, I served 8 years in the United States Marine Corps, including a deployment to Iraq from 2009 to 2010. During my time in the Infantry as a Sergeant, I developed a deep interest in the wide range of firearms we used. It fascinated me to learn why specific weapons were chosen for different missions and roles.Breaking into the firearms industry wasn't easy, but persistence paid off. While attending a trade show, I discovered the Sonoran Desert Institute. That opportunity led me to earn an Associate of Science in Firearms Technology, along with certifications as a Pistol Expert and Range Safety Officer.My passion for firearms continues to grow every day. I'm always learning, always improving, and always striving to bring that knowledge and experience to the work we do here at Urban Carry.
