Shoulder Holster vs. Hip Holster: Which Carry Method is Right for You?

Choosing the right way to carry your firearm is just as important as choosing the firearm itself. Among the most common setups are the shoulder holster and the hip holster. Both have passionate supporters — and for good reason. They offer very different benefits and trade-offs depending on your lifestyle, body type, and typical daily activities.
Let’s dig into the differences so you can decide which one fits your carry style.

1. 🕰️ Comfort & All-Day Wear

Shoulder Holster: Spreads the weight across your shoulders and back instead of your waist. This can be more comfortable for long hours of wear, especially if you’re seated most of the day or have back/hip issues. However, shoulder rigs can feel bulky under light clothing.
Hip Holster: Places the weight on your beltline. For most people, this feels natural and unobtrusive, especially with a well-designed holster and sturdy belt. Can cause pressure when seated for long periods, especially with larger firearms.

Verdict: Shoulder holsters win for prolonged sitting; hip holsters shine for mobility and simplicity.

2. 🥷 Concealment & Clothing Requirements

Shoulder Holster: Concealment generally requires a jacket, coat, or overshirt. In warm weather or casual environments, this can be a challenge.
Hip Holster: Easier to conceal with a wider range of clothing options — just a shirt or hoodie can do the job for inside-the-waistband carry.

Verdict: Hip holsters are more versatile in different climates and dress codes.

3. 💪 Draw Speed & Accessibility

Shoulder Holster: The draw motion is across the body, which can be slower for some and requires care to avoid sweeping bystanders with the muzzle. It can be faster for seated positions (vehicles, desks) where a hip draw is awkward.
Hip Holster: Direct and quick draw from the waist, ideal for standing or moving scenarios. Seated access can be slower, especially with seatbelts in play.

Verdict: Hip holsters generally win for speed on foot; shoulder holsters have the edge when drawing while seated.

4. ⚖️ Firearm Size & Weight Handling

Shoulder Holster: Excellent for carrying larger or heavier firearms. The weight is better distributed and less likely to drag your pants down.
Hip Holster: Works best with compact or mid-size guns. Heavy full-size pistols can be carried on the hip, but they’ll require a high-quality belt and holster.

Verdict: Shoulder holsters are king for big guns; hip holsters excel with smaller EDC pistols.

5. 🔒 Retention & Security

Shoulder Holster: Good retention options available, but the gun’s position may make it more accessible to someone standing behind or beside you in close quarters.
Hip Holster: More natural for you to guard and control during a struggle, especially if you’ve trained for weapon retention.

Verdict: Hip carry has a slight advantage for weapon retention in close contact situations.

Bottom Line

Choose a shoulder holster if you:

Spend long hours sitting or driving
Regularly carry a full-size or heavy firearm
Often wear jackets or coats

Choose a hip holster if you:

Need quick, consistent draw while standing
Live in a warm climate with light clothing
Want the most common, versatile carry option

The truth is, both have a place in a well-rounded carry setup. Many experienced carriers switch between them depending on the day’s activities. The best choice is the one you’ll wear comfortably and practice with consistently — because the holster you actually use is the one that matters.

Richard Calvette

Firearms Expert, Urban Carry Holsters

I've been with Urban Carry Holsters since 2020, proudly serving as the Firearms Expert. Before that, I served 8 years in the United States Marine Corps, including a deployment to Iraq from 2009 to 2010. During my time in the Infantry as a Sergeant, I developed a deep interest in the wide range of firearms we used. It fascinated me to learn why specific weapons were chosen for different missions and roles.Breaking into the firearms industry wasn't easy, but persistence paid off. While attending a trade show, I discovered the Sonoran Desert Institute. That opportunity led me to earn an Associate of Science in Firearms Technology, along with certifications as a Pistol Expert and Range Safety Officer.My passion for firearms continues to grow every day. I'm always learning, always improving, and always striving to bring that knowledge and experience to the work we do here at Urban Carry.